I finally got around to reading the first book of the His Dark Materials trilogy. I had been rather disappointed by the movie, but liked the book a lot better. (Thanks to Starstuff btw for showing me how to link to the stylish themed instance of an entry rather than the dull white page I've linked to until now.)
I managed to connect the dots a little too quickly for my liking near the end, figuring everything out before Lyra did even though I didn't actually know anything she didn't. Ah, the curse of being overly intelligent. Not to mention modest ;)
I'm quite puzzled at why TPTB decided to leave out the last part of the book when making the movie though. Yes, the movie would have gotten longer (Yes, even longer than 113 minutes, imagine that!), but didn't they see how much better of a cliffhanger the book's ending is? And how the frak can anyone miss that? I just have to quote JMS on that one, even though he of course wasraving scholarly discussing a different, though similarly astounding decision:
Anyway, I actually meant to give a quote from the book itself and we're getting to it. You might or might not have read my little comment-almost-turned-essay explaining why I was reading the Bible. I'm sorry if you don't know German and give this short version of what I said as an offering of peace: religion has influenced human history, art and whatever for thousands of years, so you can't hope to understand all of these without knowing anything about religion. Or, and this is where we finally get to the point, dear readers:
I managed to connect the dots a little too quickly for my liking near the end, figuring everything out before Lyra did even though I didn't actually know anything she didn't. Ah, the curse of being overly intelligent. Not to mention modest ;)
I'm quite puzzled at why TPTB decided to leave out the last part of the book when making the movie though. Yes, the movie would have gotten longer (Yes, even longer than 113 minutes, imagine that!), but didn't they see how much better of a cliffhanger the book's ending is? And how the frak can anyone miss that? I just have to quote JMS on that one, even though he of course was
"I mean, there’s actually a kind of awe that sets in when you begin to really understand the extent of the stupidity involved...the same kind of stunned, silent reverence that comes when you finally see the Mona Lisa up close, or the first time you hear Ode to Joy performed by a live orchestra. The sheer majestic perfection of it sends you to your knees with the realization that this is not just common stupidity, it’s a Mount Everest rising into the clouds...a level of stupidity so monumental that it actually acquires horizontal perspective, like a train disappearing into the distance."There, can't possibly put it any better than that. As a matter of fact, the two issues are rather closely related: JMS is rejoicing over "the decision by PTEN [the network that originally aired B5] to delay the final episodes of each season until the start of the subsequent season." There goes the cliffhanger...
JMS, Babylon 5 - The Scripts of J. Michael Straczynski, Volume 3
Anyway, I actually meant to give a quote from the book itself and we're getting to it. You might or might not have read my little comment-almost-turned-essay explaining why I was reading the Bible. I'm sorry if you don't know German and give this short version of what I said as an offering of peace: religion has influenced human history, art and whatever for thousands of years, so you can't hope to understand all of these without knowing anything about religion. Or, and this is where we finally get to the point, dear readers:
Lyra: "[B]ut it en't true, is it? Not true like chemistry or engineering, not that kind of true? There wasn't really an Adam and Eve?
[...]
Lord Asriel: "[T]hink of Adam and Eve like an imaginary number, like the square root of minus one: you can never see any concrete proof that it exists, but if you include it in your equations, you can calculate all manner of things that couldn't be imagined without it."
Beautiful![...]
Lord Asriel: "[T]hink of Adam and Eve like an imaginary number, like the square root of minus one: you can never see any concrete proof that it exists, but if you include it in your equations, you can calculate all manner of things that couldn't be imagined without it."
2 comments | Leave a comment

